Is It Better To Repair Or Replace A Roof?

Katelyn Lewis • September 14, 2022

The answer depends on the age, type, weathering, and ventilation of your roof.

Drone image of roof line, asphalt shingle roof.

Let’s say you have an asphalt shingle roof.

Age: In Richmond, most asphalt shingle roofs last between 17 and 25 years old. This age range also depends on the type of shingle.

Type: If you have a 3-tab, or flat-looking, shingle, its age range is lower – about 15 to 20 years – while an architectural, dimensional-looking shingle can last up to 25 or even 30 years. We actually replaced a 40-year old roof recently, though it was well past its prime!

Weathering: Mother Nature can be brutal. If any hail storms, hurricanes, or other severe wind or weather events have occurred, they may have worn down your roof prematurely.

Ventilation: An improperly ventilated roof can prematurely age your shingles, as they are unable to “breathe.”

So, let’s say you notice a new leak in your 10-year old roof. If there’s no extensive hail or wind damage, it’s likely that you can simply repair your roof without breaking the bank. If, however, you notice a leak on your 22-year-old roof, replacing your roof may be more beneficial and money-saving than repairing it.

If you’re not sure, Retex Roofing & Exteriors is here to help. We offer complimentary roof assessments in which we consider all of these factors while we examine your roof.

Eliminate the guesswork. Call us today at 804-258-6300 for a complimentary roof assessment today.

CONTACT RETEX
Standing seam metal roof replacement in Providence Forge, VA.
By Katelyn Lewis December 12, 2025
RETEX replaced the asphalt shingles on this Providence Forge home in July 2024 with a standing seam metal roof in “ivy green” color.
RETEX's Andy Connor.
By Katelyn Lewis December 11, 2025
Join us in wishing a happy birthday to Andy Connor, one of our fantastic exterior experts,
Chimney repointing in North Chesterfield, VA.
By Katelyn Lewis December 9, 2025
Chimney repointing fixes the mortar seals between the bricks of your chimney.
Roof replacement with Tamko Stormfighter shingles.
By Katelyn Lewis December 3, 2025
Most asphalt shingles require warmer temperatures to install safely, but TAMKO’s StormFighter shingles are designed for lower-temperature installs.
RETEX standing seam metal roof replacement in Richmond, 23222.
By Katelyn Lewis December 2, 2025
Richmond homeowner Joy Shepperson reached out to RETEX in October 2025 after noticing a leak down one of her home’s walls.
Group photo of RETEX employees.
By Katelyn Lewis November 29, 2025
We’re proud to be a locally owned home exterior company serving Richmond, Fredericksburg, and Charlottesville – built on craftsmanship, care, and community.
Retex team group shot.
By Katelyn Lewis November 27, 2025
We’re feeling festive in light of Thanksgiving, so bare with us as we take a moment to share our thanks.
Stock image of Thanksgiving meal.
By Katelyn Lewis November 25, 2025
Our office will be closed starting Wednesday, Nov. 25, through Sunday, Nov. 30, as we take time to celebrate with our friends and family.
Moseley homeowner Mark Palmer chose RETEX to replace his roof and gutters in December 2021.
By Katelyn Lewis November 20, 2025
Moseley homeowner Mark Palmer chose RETEX to replace his roof and gutters in December 2021.
Severe gutter damage on home in Richmond, VA.
By Katelyn Lewis November 19, 2025
Here are key indicators to look for if you think your gutters may be getting to the end of their lifespan.